Mnstf board meeting, Aug 10, 6pm on Jitsi, Attending board members: Matt Strait, Aaron Vander Giessen, Scott Raun, Linda Lounsbury, Eric Forste. Others attending: Minicon 55 chairs Sharla Stremski and Don Stremski. == Approve last meeting's minutes == Approved! == Conventions, part 1 == We'll start with this so that Don and Sharla don't have to wait through the rest of the agenda. * Minicon 55 (2021?) What are we going to do? Concern is expressed about any sort of virtual con kind of idea, because we are not good at tech. But if we did want to do anything virtual, we definitely would want to start planning now. Don points out that one of our GoH is currently on the other side of a closed international border. He is inclined to pull the plug on an in-person Minicon in 2021. With the current restrictions, we are in force majeure territory (unless the hotel wants to claim that we aren't a social event), but of course we have no idea whether that will be true in April -- 8 months from now. (Currently social gatherings larger than 10 people and any gathering over 250 are banned in Minnesota. That's in Minnesota's "Stay Safe Plan", phase 3. It's unclear how we'd move to phase 4, and also the rules for phase 4 haven't been set.) Matt would like something written from the hotel, like an e-mail, in which they agree that under the current restrictions, the event is illegal and therefore we both walk away with no penalty. But a lot of the staff is furloughed at the moment, which makes all kinds of communication with the hotel difficult. Even under the most optimistic scenario of a vaccine very soon, we'd have to negotiate with the hotel about how we don't lose a huge amount of money on a much smaller Minicon, because many people still won't come, and therefore won't rent rooms. (Because some people won't tolerate the vaccine, or they'll still be in line for it, or because they'll just be skittish from the last year, etc.) We don't know when hotel staff will be back so that we can talk to them about it. Aaron can try to find out. Currently our penalty, if somehow we felt like paying it, would be $8400. That's until October. But there's really no reason to think about paying it. When do we need to make a decision? We don't think we're going to really learn anything new in the next few months. How long does Minicon take to plan? Matt says we usually do it in about three months even though we have all year. If we wanted to convert it into a relaxacon, or close to one, that would take less time. Scott suggests, therefore, that we not attempt to make a final decision until about January, but that between now and then we talk with the hotel as much as possible about different scenarios. Sharla asks what the financial situation is if it's legal to have it, but Minicon is extremely small. Matt says for a 200 person Minicon, we lose $7k, plus we have to pay for all the room nights we don't make, which might be around $16k if we missed our room block by half ($23k total). So that would be bad, but we're (Matt's) hoping that the hotel sees it in its interest for us to have the con (so they get *some* revenue), and would like us to be repeat customers, and would work with us to make it not ruinous. Linda asks what happens if the governmental restrictions are lifted, but we don't think it's safe. Matt says, well, that's the risk we're taking by not cancelling now. Cancelling now, taking the $8k hit, would be the most conservative thing to do, but no one present wants to cancel right now. Don is willing to wait, although not super happy about it. If we canceled in February, about the latest that we could make a decision and still plan a decent con, the penalty is $25k. But we all agree that the risk of having to pay this $25k is pretty low. It requires that there's no available vaccine, and governmental restrictions are lifted, and the hotel is totally unreasonable. We should have the chairs to a meeting again by October. * Minicon 56 Matt would like to know if Don and Sharla believe they've signed up to run two Minicons, whenever they are, or if they signed up to run Minicons in 2020 and 2021, if possible? They don't want to answer this question until Minicon 55 is firmly scheduled, which is totally fair. Matt just points out that usually we have the following Minicon lined up before the current one so that we can announced GoH and take registrations, etc. He'll just ask this question again later. == Next meeting == With the Minicon 55 chairs. Sept 21, 6pm, on Jitsi. == Review TODO list == * (2020-06) Eric will run proposed virtual meeting bylaws language past Laura and Michael -- Eric reached out to them. No response from Laura. Michael said that he was fine with him. See discussion below. * (2020-07) Linda will talk to Don at Uncle Hugo's about us buying $1000 of books by authors of color from him and sending them to libraries/community centers/etc. to (predominately) reach readers of color -- Linda has talked to Don, and he can do that. One complication is that a lot of stuff is only available in trade paperback at ~$18 each. We might just have to live with the lower count. Linda also talked with Northside Achievement Zone, who do student mentoring, to see if they would have use for books from us. The Phyllis Wheatley Center said they don't have programs for children over 11. Scott suggests that Linda talk to Moon Palace Books about children/YA books. * (2020-07) Matt will talk to Greg at Dreamhaven about us buying $300 of books, as above -- Greg says sure, he can do that. Matt should have the books in hand in a couple of weeks. He has the list of titles in hand. He's forwarded it to board-chat so Linda can use it. * (2020-07) Matt will talk to Quartermaster Brother Joe about making sure our stuff is still in the storage locker -- Matt has e-mailed Brother Joe and he said sure, but he hasn't heard the result. Aaron and Emily conspire to make sure he knows how to get in. Done: * (2020-07) Matt will write up language for the bylaws to allow the pandemic voting member rules we want. And the rules for announcing amendments needs to be updated. Done. See below. * (2020-07) Matt will write a sentence that says that people can petition the board if they feel they are being locked out of voting status for 2021. Done, and here it is: "Because of pandemic restrictions on in-person meetings, the board has relaxed the requirements for voting membership. We have clarified that virtual social meetings do count towards the 5 required meetings, and have also made everyone who was eligible to vote in 2020 also a voting member for 2021. We hope this covers nearly everyone's situation fairly, but if you will still have trouble achieving voting status, the board is happy to hear from you: board@mnstf.org." * (2020-07) Matt will send bills for past due accounts -- Done. * (2020-07) As he will do every time, Matt will announce the next meeting to all our officers -- Done. * (2020-07) Scott will talk to Carol about sending a $500 check to GPS. Check written and went in the mail today. The Sept-Oct check to the storage locker went out with it. (We are billed monthly, but Carol decided to pay for two months this time.) * (2020-07) Aaron will invite Don and Sharla to this board meeting, and maybe the one after that if necessary. That happened! == Review recurring task list == Matt doesn't see anything that needs doing, nor does anyone else. == PO Box == As of Aug 8, Hershey says she has not picked up the mail has not been picked up since about a week before our post office was torched in the George Floyd riots. Matt has urged her to go try and pick up our mail from wherever it is being directed now. Hershey thinks she knows, but hasn't checked yet. Matt will pester her about getting the mail. == Website update == Scott and Matt have seen some proposed new style sheets. Scott says that Matt should make a proposal to the board about the one he likes. Matt will do that. == Bylaws == Four amendments are on the table: * We previously agreed to add a sentence at the end of III.3: "Only hand-marked paper ballots shall be used." We still like this. * We are also looking to amend the bylaws to formalize the policy about virtual meetings. Matt wrote some language, previously appearing in the June board minutes, and here it is again. It is a new sub-paragraph, III.6.b, (under III.6, "Recorded attendance at various types of meetings shall count or not count towards voting membership, as follows:"): ***** b) For meetings of one of the types defined in (a) that include the possibility of remote attendance: i) For the regular annual meeting, remote attendees of the business meeting shall count towards voting membership ii) For special meetings of the members, remote attendance shall count towards voting membership by discretion of the board of directors iii) For regularly established social meetings, if the meeting is intended to be primarily attended remotely and/or all social interactions occur through the remote connection platform, attendance shall count towards voting membership, but not otherwise iv) For general convention committee meetings, remote attendance shall count towards voting membership at the discretion of the chair, or their designate For meetings in which remote attendance counts towards voting membership, it shall be the responsibility of the host to provide the remote attendance list to the Membership Secretary. ***** It's a bit complicated, but that's because it has to fit in with the rest of the bylaws, which are a bit complicated. As above, Michael says he's fine with it, so we're good with it, and will go ahead and adopt it. * And to clarify that posting bylaws amendments at virtual meetings counts for purposes of having the new bylaws take effect as per By-law X. The current language is "Such alterations or amendments take immediate effect upon a single publication in Rune, in Einblatt, or after being posted for a two-month period in a prominent place at Society meetings." Matt notes that this wording also seems to assume that any two-month period would have plenty of meetings in it. He suggests: "Such alterations or amendments take immediate effect upon a single publication in Rune, in Einblatt, or after being announced and made available at three consecutive Society meetings." We all like this. * And, finally, to allow us to declare that all 2020 voting members are 2021 voting members. Matt proposes adding a paragraph I.2.b.i: "i) In addition, all persons who were voting members at the beginning of the 2020-2021 membership period shall also be voting members for the 2021-2022 membership period." After some discussion of the technicalities of what it means to be a voting member, and the history of those technicalities, we like this one too. (In short, voting member status currently persists all year, and besides letting you vote for the board, allows you to call a special meeting with 1/4 of the voting members. As far as we know, there has never been a special meeting.) Matt will put them all together into a single document, and then we'll have to figure out how to sign it, which we want to do. A round-robin letter, we suppose. == More conventions == * Decongestant 5 Yeah, we should cancel it. We'd like to not pay the cancellation fee. Force majeure almost certainly applies. Matt will get on this. * Decongestant 6 Nothing to discuss. We'll plan this when it's possible to plan things. * Minneapolis in 2073 No news. == Adjourned == == New TODO list == * (2020-07) Linda will continue working to buy a pile of books from Uncle Hugo's. * (2020-07) Matt will continue working to buy a pile of books from Dreamhaven. * (2020-07) Matt will see if Brother Joe found our stuff still in the storage locker. * (2020-08) Matt will ask Hershey if she's gotten the mail. * (2020-08) Matt will propose one of the new designs for the website to the board. * (2020-08) Matt will put all the bylaws amendments together. * (2020-08) Aaron will talk to the Minicon hotel. * (2020-08) Matt will, as usual, announce the next board meeting to all our officers. >> Perpetually recurring items for next time: * Approve last meeting's minutes * Review TODO list * Review recurring task list * Conventions * Next meeting >> Also for next time: * Bylaws amendments